I have just returned from attending the family celebration of Passover down in Florida. It was lovely and I had an excellent time. But one thing happened that was simultaneously very entertaining and completely appalling.
We were lolling about through our meal and enjoying a traditional form of Orthodox Jewish entertainment, a nice argument about a very finicky point of Jewish law. So it was getting a bit heated as we debated this issue, which was about counting the days leading up to Shavuot, known as counting the Omer, and what happens to your Omer count if you fly from Australia to LA -- do you simply count the same count as everybody in LA when you land, or do you continue counting as if you were still in Australia, allowing for crossing the date line. So we were trying to pin down whether you are counting based on the passing of sunset or based on the passing of hours of time. And it was becoming more and more clear that our nephews didn't really seem to grasp what Norm was trying to convey about the international date line. And then, jokingly, I said, "you DO realize the Earth rotates round the Sun, right?" And I was just joking, just making a snarky crack.
My nephew replied, firmly, "no, the Sun goes around the Earth."
So I said, "whoa, hold up there, what?" Norman and I turn our faces toward the young man -- he's 19 or so at this point, having already graduated from his intensely conservative Chassidic yeshiva school. (12 hours a day, 6 days a week, folks.) We stared at him and he calmly explained to us that Ramban, Nachmanides as he is sometimes known, says this in his commentary. We mentioned to him that Ramban wrote this sometime late in the 11th century and that science today says something a bit different and he simply replied that science is wrong.
I am not making this up.
My nephew, a simple young man who probably suffers from undiagnosed, untreated Asperger's, believed what his Rabbis at school taught him, and honestly believes that the Sun revolves around the Earth.
As if that isn't awe-inspiringly insane enough, I later heard him explaining very seriously to his mother that it was clearly all true, had to be true, because Ramban checked his own writings with Moshe Rabbenu. You know, Moshe? The dude in the Bible, the staff, the Exodus, the 40 years in the desert? That Moshe? So, his mother said to him that this made little sense, since Moshe was dead by the time Ramban wrote his works. And the young man replied that it didn't matter when Moshe died; he knew it was true because his Rabbi had told him this story. I so very very very badly wanted to butt in there and ask him a whole mess of questions. But my mother-in-law glared at me and made me stay out of it. Which nearly killed me, as you may well imagine.
My sister-in-law provided further insanity. She turned to us and explained that this is exactly why she doesn't teach the Solar System in her classes -- she works at the same school her sons attend -- she said there's no way she can make it make sense, so she just doesn't teach it. Which, of course, means that she has known all along that the school her sons attend has actually been teaching them 11th-century cosmological theory as if it were fact. She is completely complicit in this bizarre mockery of an education that those poor young fellows are receiving. Nor did she seem properly ashamed of herself. And of course her husband seemed quite placidly calm about it. Clearly he was completely at peace with having children who have missed the last 10 centuries of scientific advances. (I suppose I should be grateful that the Alter Rebbe never took a stand against modern medicine.) Understand, these two people both graduated actual American colleges. Yet there it is. They've chosen a path for their children that leads straight into intellectual Nowhere. Actually, the husband is pretty much in intellectual Nowhere himself; he entertained us considerably when he explained to us that of COURSE we would have been enslaved by the Egyptians forever had God not rescued us, since the Egyptians practiced BLACK MAGIC. Yes, he really said that. With a totally straight face.
When we first got out of the house and drove off, my husband was furious and I was still laughing uncontrollably over it. But now a few days have passed and I'm coming around to his way of thinking. It's a bit of a tragedy, really. We make choices for our children all the time and we can't always know the effects these choices will have, after all. We have to choose what we think will be right. But in this case, what could they possibly be thinking? It would be completely hilarious except that I actually know the people involved and so it is pretty saddening in the final analysis.
It's particularly bizarre because this backward thinking is in NO WAY representative of religious Jewish education in general. There are extremely rigorous yeshivas all over the East coast, the entire country I guess, which teach plain old regular science like any other school. My husband and father-in-law both attended such schools. This wacky old-school cosmological crap is something that seems to be the thing only in certain circles, and my brother-in-law is deliberately steering his family deeper into those waters. And no one really understands why.
But I must say, it's amazing to come face-to-face with someone who truly, honestly believes in something that is just completely wrong that way. I mean, it's not something nebulous like the existence of a Deity or Magick or Xenu or something imaginary or un-provable. He really believes the Sun goes around the Earth! Even though we've sent men to the Moon and all that stuff is really not a theory anymore but actual proven fact! It was like seeing a Unicorn or something. Gobsmacked does not even begin to cover my feelings.